Dogs vs Cats: The Diversity Paradox

Wissenschaft & Technik

To make our work paw-sible, join us on Patreon at patreon.com/MinuteEarth!
Different dogs look incredibly different - but that doesn't mean they are necessarily more diverse.
LEARN MORE
**************
To learn more about this topic, start your googling with these keywords:
phenotypic diversity - the range of different observable traits in a certain organism - for example, size, color, strength, and friendliness.
genetic diversity - the variation in the genetic information within and among individuals of a population or species
artificial selection (or selective breeding) - a process used by humans to develop new organisms with desirable characteristics
SUPPORT MINUTEEARTH
**************************
If you like what we do, you can help us!:
- Become our patron: patreon.com/MinuteEarth
- Share this video with your friends and family
- Leave us a comment (we read them!)
CREDITS
*********
Kate Yoshida | Script Writer, Narrator and Director
Josh Taira | Illustration, Video Editing and Animation
Nathaniel Schroeder | Music
MinuteEarth is produced by Neptune Studios LLC
neptunestudios.info
OUR STAFF
************
Sarah Berman • Arcadi Garcia Rius
David Goldenberg • Julián Gustavo Gómez
Melissa Hayes • Alex Reich • Henry Reich
Peter Reich • Ever Salazar • Kate Yoshida
OUR LINKS
************
DElevel | delevel.info
TikTok | tiktok.com/@minuteearth
Twitter | MinuteEarth
Instagram | minute_earth
Facebook | Minuteearth
Website | minuteearth.com
Apple Podcasts| podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/minuteearth/id649211176

REFERENCES
**************
Hedrick P. & Andersson L. (2011) Are dogs genetically special? Heredity 106: 712-713. www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3186234/
Lampi S. et al. (2020) Variation in breeding practices and geographic isolation drive subpopulation differentiation, contributing to the loss of genetic diversity within dog breed lineages. Canine Medicine and Genetics 7(1): 1-10. cgejournal.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s40575-020-00085-9
Lyons L. (2009) Recent advances in cat genetics. CAB Reviews: Perspectives in Agriculture, Veterinary Science, Nutrition and Natural Resources, Volume 4. ucdavis.pure.elsevier.com/en/publications/recent-advances-in-cat-genetics
Menotti-Raymond M. et al. (2008) Patterns of molecular genetic variation among cat breeds. Genomics 91(1): 1-11. www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0888754307002078?via%3Dihub
Ostrander E. & Wayne R. (2005) The canine genome. Genome Research 15(12):1706-16. pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16339369/
Parker H. et al. (2004) Genetic structure of the purebred domestic dog. Science 304: 1160-4. science.sciencemag.org/content/304/5674/1160
Plassais J. et al. (2019) Whole genome sequencing of canids reveals genomic regions under selection and variants influencing morphology. Nature Communications 10. www.nature.com/articles/s41467-019-09373-w

KOMMENTARE

  • MinuteEarth
    MinuteEarthVor Monat

    Thanks for making us the luckiest dogs on DElevel! Want to become our Patreon or member on DElevel? Just visit www.patreon.com/MinuteEarth or click "JOIN". Thanks!

  • Daniel Standford

    Daniel Standford

    Vor 4 Tage

    whats up with the positivity around selective breeding? you guys seem to really be ignoring all of those comments

  • Rithul Sincer

    Rithul Sincer

    Vor Monat

    I like cats when I see a dog I don’t want to see because when is it barks so loudly I get scared

  • Jason Bateman

    Jason Bateman

    Vor Monat

    1 why do we need to know the name of the narrator while other videos they just go along with it saving minutes? will knowing kate help us in the video? no 2 it sounds like she tries super hard to be cute and eccentric, just lay it all out next time we've been watching your videos and some of them just strikes us as really try hard pedantic

  • briansmutti

    briansmutti

    Vor Monat

    please lose the repetitive music it distracts from the narrative and the narrative is a bit sing-songy too which also distracts i can’t finish watching this as it is forced and sounds phony

  • Yusuf Ginnah

    Yusuf Ginnah

    Vor Monat

    Was feeling a li'l cat-atonic until watching the video... Thanks for the upload! Instant sub for you!! 😎👍🏼

  • JQN d-_-b
    JQN d-_-bVor 3 Tage

    Yea don't... Don't do what we did to dogs with cats. There are already some breeds sharing similar health problems like the flat nosed cats that are "cute" but also are a fur ball of breathing difficulties

  • Yung Thunder
    Yung ThunderVor 4 Tage

    Breeding dogs into specific species was incredibly bad for their health. It would be a travesty if humans did the same to cats

  • Daniel Standford
    Daniel StandfordVor 4 Tage

    this video, while quite informative sets a REALLY bad example so innocently. Its obvious this video is something that, while not made for kids, is very welcoming of the concept of a teacher showing it in class. It acts like an educational video while regularly throwing in seemingly uninformed opinions about selective breeding. It explains the concept well but completely glosses over any sort of health concerns for the animals and even at the end humors the idea of selectively breeding cats like you would flying cars or some shit. The people at MinuteEarth obviously did quite a bit of research on this topic and arent incapable people which is why im honestly a little disgusted that by being so neutral on the topic that theyve at least somewhat shown that they are willing to turn a blind eye to something like this on a video where they know could hit a million people. They have such a positive hue the entire video its honestly frustrating. Im a bit more than disappointed in this and im even more upset on the fact that they never mention it, the completely lack of acknowledgement

  • Pheonix1328
    Pheonix1328Vor 5 Tage

    You make it seem like giant cats would someone be worse than what giant dogs are now. That's like saying giant dogs are as dangerous and wolves because they're the same size.

  • Cambie X
    Cambie XVor 5 Tage

    Yeah I hope to god we don’t inbreed cats to the point we have for dogs. Let’s keep the genetic diversity they have, which in turn we have healthy cats.

  • Kerma
    KermaVor 5 Tage

    2:10 "the cat-egories" made me chuckle

  • Ireallyreally Hategoogle
    Ireallyreally HategoogleVor 6 Tage

    "breeding giant cats" Do you know about tigers?

  • Bonecrusher Slayer
    Bonecrusher SlayerVor 6 Tage

    delevel.info/stream/eInOZZKhmZqAlpk/video.html

  • Bonecrusher Slayer
    Bonecrusher SlayerVor 6 Tage

    delevel.info/stream/dIq4qK-ZjHWta3M/video.html

  • Aymen DZ
    Aymen DZVor 6 Tage

    the only thing excessive breeding has done is make animals like dogs suffer sever health consequences

  • Kingdomall
    KingdomallVor 7 Tage

    cats are clearly better because (from my experience) they tend to have less problems than varying dogs do.

  • Poisonsword
    PoisonswordVor 7 Tage

    Tbh if in the future we bred giant cats dogs would have done it sooner since they got the change first

  • Seba
    SebaVor 7 Tage

    Giant cats... so what are Lions, cheetas, panthers etc

  • Emi A
    Emi AVor 7 Tage

    now i want a giant cat, thanks o.0

  • HelmenHjelmen
    HelmenHjelmenVor 7 Tage

    love how this video compered dog species to human species

  • Reese Hendricksen
    Reese HendricksenVor 8 Tage

    Breading a cat is like herding them, it only ends poorly.

  • Weyoun Six
    Weyoun SixVor 8 Tage

    Nobody wants to talk about that this is also largely because dogs are so overbred in disgusting ways so often

  • Leia Jiang
    Leia JiangVor 8 Tage

    Dogs are great no matter what they look like

  • catz537
    catz537Vor 8 Tage

    Yeah no I don't think we should deform cats the way we did dogs. So many dog breeds have health problems because of irresponsible breeding

  • soroush kowsarian
    soroush kowsarianVor 8 Tage

    "their *cat* agory"

  • Londronable
    LondronableVor 8 Tage

    I adore my Brit short hair but even as chill as she is people do grasp that she has no problem sometimes with putting her nails into the back of my hand right when I rub her head too much or something? Big cats in the house with the claws they have seem like a bad idea.

  • Londronable
    LondronableVor 9 Tage

    As a cat person I fucking hate how people don't take the race of the cat into account. You don't put a farm cat in an apartment building. Similar some cat species are best kept more inside. Though most of those will happily go inside again quickly if left outside. My British shorthair is outside every day but comes back inside less than 30 minutes later. Often with a mouse(we live next to a swamp) Because of the similar looks there are many people who have no idea that different breeds require different things.

  • Amethyst_Warrior Schl
    Amethyst_Warrior SchlVor 9 Tage

    I see a lot of comments talking about how we shouldn't do to cats as we did with dogs. They don't seem to understand that we can breed out the poor genes. We did it with horses.

  • Anton Larsson
    Anton LarssonVor 9 Tage

    Wait, hang on, back it up. Beep beep beep. Are you saying onto me, that in the future we can have cats like the one Ozymandias has in Watchmen? Because sign me up!

  • Anton Larsson
    Anton LarssonVor 9 Tage

    Oh my goodness. It hurts. Being pelted with so many terrible puns, urgh.

  • Petra44YT Nein!
    Petra44YT Nein!Vor 10 Tage

    What's with the stupid "music"? It's VERY distracting!

  • Luna Moonlock
    Luna MoonlockVor 10 Tage

    I WANT A GIANT CAT And by that I mean my 1 goal in life is to someday own a male maine coon because those things get BIG

  • a fucking paper bag
    a fucking paper bagVor 10 Tage

    I hope humanity won't fuck up cats as much as they did with dogs. But even when that happens I'll already be in my grave, so I can sleep peacefully.

  • lara
    laraVor 10 Tage

    Kind of like birds - they come in all shapes and sizes

  • Usamin M
    Usamin MVor 11 Tage

    omg this video actually got me so annoyed. "careful breeding" jfc give it another 100 years and cats will no even behave like cats anymore

  • Iliad Novak
    Iliad NovakVor 11 Tage

    In other words, no one likes cats, so they don't have as many breeds.

  • Finn Snow
    Finn SnowVor 11 Tage

    Summary: Dogs are super inbred and cats are less inbred

  • Linn Kirksaether
    Linn KirksaetherVor 11 Tage

    Liked for the punchline.

  • Miguel Galang
    Miguel GalangVor 11 Tage

    I once stepped on the cat's tail when I was catsitting for my mom. When my mom arrived, the bish started saying "meeeew meew meow meeeeeeeeew" and then my mom threw a pillow at me for stepping on his tail. Should I be concerned?

  • Meerzy 1
    Meerzy 1Vor 12 Tage

    I don’t like how this video frames selective breeding of animals in a good way but looking at the comments I think most people realize that it is wrong.

  • Seth Apex
    Seth ApexVor 12 Tage

    If you mix with a race that is significantly distant from yours, you will be more closely related to a random person of your own race than your own child.

  • Murphie_wdwlimelight
    Murphie_wdwlimelightVor 14 Tage

    Cats domesticated themselves and we domesticated dogs. Simple.

  • Paul Douris
    Paul DourisVor 14 Tage

    Jesus is king and our savior repent of sin amen

  • Andi
    AndiVor 14 Tage

    No give me the giant cats now!

  • Mali Cia
    Mali CiaVor 14 Tage

    I want a giant version of my boyfriends cat. I don't care if he tries to eat me. The cuddles would be glorious!

  • LightningQueen 11
    LightningQueen 11Vor 15 Tage

    Everyone's talking about lions, pumas, tigers, and other giant predators, but where's the serval gang at? They're big and majestic and some people actually have them as pets! Though it takes a lot of effort to raise one in order to keep it from murdering you. But really, servals are beautiful and exist in the current day.

  • Adam Yell
    Adam YellVor 16 Tage

    i don't like how many casual jabs at cats this video takes.

  • Tvesha Chauhan
    Tvesha ChauhanVor 16 Tage

    So if the genetic diversity between 2 humans is like 0.1%, why does racism still exist? I know this isnt the point of this video but just a thought...

  • Yuubi Timbergrim
    Yuubi TimbergrimVor 16 Tage

    I apprecate the pawns, but i do want giant pet cats

  • Isabelle H.
    Isabelle H.Vor 16 Tage

    Breeding is bullshit for multiple reasons, and talking about it as something fun and quirky is dangerous and disappointing

  • Jackson
    JacksonVor 16 Tage

    plz do not breed cats, we've already messed up 1 animal lets not do it to the others

  • Kate Altman
    Kate AltmanVor 17 Tage

    Aw. Kitteh photos!

  • Jacoby Boyer
    Jacoby BoyerVor 17 Tage

    I'm with Stafan, lets make sure that we don't mess with cats like we did dogs. I like my Cattos good and healthy.

  • BlueMenpachi
    BlueMenpachiVor 19 Tage

    It's my running theory that the only thing stopping house cats from ruling the world, is that we can pick them up. Also don't do to cats what we've done to dogs, cats already inbreed enough as it is.

  • Unwanted Outlaw
    Unwanted OutlawVor 19 Tage

    My cat is already pretty big...he can reach up to the kitchen counter...

  • Michaela Hovey
    Michaela HoveyVor 19 Tage

    Do not encourage people to do this to cats. Why the heck did you make this video?

  • Deanastasya
    DeanastasyaVor 19 Tage

    don't breed cats i am so sorry for some sad sickly dog breeds already, leave them alone. Your dogs are all very cute! they also have health issues, and i know there could be some extra cute cats but it is not worth it

  • FireballReviews
    FireballReviewsVor 20 Tage

    I'm pro giant cats. Just sayin.

  • zhchristiana
    zhchristianaVor 20 Tage

    Cats tend to care little whether they hurt you (e.g. while playing). I'd like them to stay small please

  • Jianna Sandoval
    Jianna SandovalVor 20 Tage

    I'm no expert but I know: Orange cat, calico cat, short-haired, long haired, Siamese, sphynx cat.. aaannd that's about it

  • Uly
    UlyVor 21 Tag

    Maine Coons: Am I joke to you?

  • Gail All
    Gail AllVor 21 Tag

    Hmm... cat breeds... I know: stray cat fancy cat that's it

  • Mariana CamachoF
    Mariana CamachoFVor 22 Tage

    Cat-egories I see what you did there

  • jorgelotr
    jorgelotrVor 22 Tage

    There are breeds of cats that are quite big (~>1.5 m) and others quite smaller. Still not the huge difference between dog breeds, though.

  • Sepia Smith
    Sepia SmithVor 22 Tage

    I have a feeling it's because of crazy and unhealthy selective breeding. Poor dogs. Bull terriers, pugs, german shepherds, dachshunds, etc.

  • TORTOİSE
    TORTOİSEVor 22 Tage

    WİNNER CATS 😁😁😁

  • Hurbig
    HurbigVor 22 Tage

    I think giant cats are called tigers

  • will
    willVor 24 Tage

    please don't inbreed cats. it's already bad enough that there's people breeding short-legged cats

  • A p q H
    A p q HVor 24 Tage

    We didn't breed dogs carefully, we bred them obsessively (and in a lot of cases, selected on the wrong things). If we had bred them carefully we would have healtier dogs

  • Sayumi Nakano
    Sayumi NakanoVor 25 Tage

    Cat-egories, cat-astrophe. 21 century humor👌

  • Raul Salustiano
    Raul SalustianoVor 25 Tage

    Não entendi nada mais muito bom ótimo vídeo

  • Sylvie Ficco
    Sylvie FiccoVor 25 Tage

    I mean there are larger cat breeds ragdolls, Maine coons, Siberians, Norwegian forest cats, and savannah but savannahs shouldn't exist and are banned in several states. There's also very small cat breeds like the Singapura. Female singapura can be 5 pounds one average they are defiantly smaller than mixed breeds/ domestic shorthairs.

  • Star God
    Star GodVor 25 Tage

    The little heart that popped up when she mentions breeding cats, that was adorable

  • Josué Neves
    Josué NevesVor 25 Tage

    You forgot the part where we in our vanity caused suffering and pain to these animal messing with their dna for our own amusement leading to a variety of breathing problems cardiac diseases joint problems etc.

  • MiniBlackTigers
    MiniBlackTigersVor 25 Tage

    You did not draw any black cats!

  • It’s Viola Rose
    It’s Viola RoseVor 25 Tage

    Oh, we breed cats deliberately. It's just that you don't mess with perfection. Also you haven't included larger breeds of field cat, and other felines like the ocecat, ocelot and tiger which can technically be domesticated, but are scary as hell. In theory you could throw tiger DNA into the housecat mix, as they've done with ocelots to create the ocecat, but they don't thank you for it. Ultimately small and lazy, lying in a sunbeam is a cats ultimate form. And as there is evidence of selective breeding in ancient Egypt, this whole video is kinda bupkiss. But I enjoyed the cute animal pics though!

  • Kyrkogrim
    KyrkogrimVor 27 Tage

    There are already some pretty large cats, such as Savannah's, Norweigian Forest Cats and Maine coons

  • Karen Poppins
    Karen PoppinsVor 27 Tage

    These puns were very FURnny

  • avi12
    avi12Vor 27 Tage

    2:11 I see what you did there, "cat-egories"

  • Liesel Brehmer
    Liesel BrehmerVor 28 Tage

    Yeah, how 'bout we DON'T breed cats like we did dogs. I'd like for cats to keep living as long as 14-16 years and for them to stay healthy by not inbreeding them.

  • alwong604
    alwong604Vor 28 Tage

    Cats are evil

  • 90Entergetical aka Bot3141
    90Entergetical aka Bot3141Vor 29 Tage

    The two cat jokes made me laugh so hard

  • JG R
    JG RVor Monat

    well, Pumas are technically "small cats", so I'd never want to see a 4ft tall house cat.

  • Ro Tluanga
    Ro TluangaVor Monat

    Why are we making dog less skilled over century

  • Josefine
    JosefineVor Monat

    1:02 the dots are not alligned :/

  • Silender
    SilenderVor Monat

    I want giant cat instead of horse.

  • -Warlocket -
    -Warlocket -Vor Monat

    Cats like munchkins, Scottish folds and Persians almost always have serious health issues due to their deformities, not to mention that if any of those cats are completely white there’s actually a huge chance that they will be deaf, breeding like that seriously needs to stop, #AdoptDontShop

  • Obama _man9
    Obama _man9Vor Monat

    I don’t feel like breeding larger cates would be a very good idea

  • Ezrad Lionel
    Ezrad LionelVor Monat

    Short Answer: We don't breed cats because they have not given us permission to do so

  • Soken50
    Soken50Vor Monat

    I mean if you want a big cat you can already aim for lions, tigers, panthers, ect... You might wanna select for tameness VERY carefully though lest you get mauled to death for forgetting to fill their bowl.

  • Man Doo
    Man DooVor Monat

    If we will breed them we might end up with Australian size cats

  • Akumako Cross
    Akumako CrossVor Monat

    How about we don’t breed our cats into oblivion like we’ve done to dogs, causing all sorts of deformations, physical problems, and genetic diseases. Inbreeding isn’t good for organisms.

  • Диана Кузьмина
    Диана КузьминаVor Monat

    Cats are less vulnerable to any mutations

  • Sephie
    SephieVor Monat

    There are breeds of cat that vary drastically in size, the Singapura is the smallest breed of cat while the Mainecoon is the largest breed of cat, coming close in size to the original ancestor of cats. Munchkin cats are the Dachshund of the cat world while Oriental Short/Longhairs are the sighthounds of the cat world. There are breeds that drastic vastly, Persians have very long, thick coats, large eyes and next to no muzzle while the Oriental Shorthair has normal eyes, long muzzle, impossibly long legs and a very short coat. I really think more breeds of cat should have been looked at, yes, there are some breeds where it's hard to tell them apart, but there are many where there is a drastic difference in facial structure, coat type, size and body build.

  • Michael Yeh
    Michael YehVor Monat

    Don't we have giant cats already?

  • Mariana Gaioso
    Mariana GaiosoVor Monat

    Giant cats, also known as lions

  • Sebastjans Slavitis
    Sebastjans SlavitisVor Monat

    scientist: let's breed giant cat cat: so you have chosen death...

  • Blackie
    BlackieVor Monat

    does that explain why my cat acts like a leopard? or wait is she actually one? idk

  • Amyaya- bwah!

    Amyaya- bwah!

    Vor 27 Tage

    It depends because there are some cat breeds that literally have direct ancestry from other cat species. Examples could be the Savannah cat (domestic cat × serval), Bristol (domestic cat × margay) or Chausie (domestic cat × jungle cat). You can go even more specific as well, with breeds like the Pantherette, Euro-Chausie, Highlander, Jungle-curl... the list goes on

  • Juhn egg
    Juhn eggVor Monat

    You ever wonder how a large dog can mate with a poodle? You are now, and are now confused

  • Maree Bee
    Maree BeeVor Monat

    I think cats are purrfect just the way they are. I’m pretty satisfied with the breeds now. And a cat the size of like a Doberman would be terrifying. (Even though I’m a cat person)

  • Brian Yim
    Brian YimVor Monat

    housecats aren't evolved from big cats they are small since day 1, but housedogs are evolved from big dogs(wolves). Also there are no benefits to breed cats to be even smaller.

  • Camo 64
    Camo 64Vor Monat

    “We might want to consider whether breeding giant cats might be a giant catastrophe” Maine Coons: are we a joke to you?

  • Gaster
    GasterVor Monat

    2:10 oh CAT-egories

  • PP
    PPVor Monat

    Just imagine street cats with a height of one meter (for the outliers around 3,3 feet) or more. The city wouldnt be a safe place, yet i still would risk my life and pspsps a cat... -.-

Nächster